The Baxter Inn
The Baxter Inn is a below-street whisky bar on Clarence Street, tucked behind an unmarked entrance down a laneway staircase. It runs one of the deeper whisky walls in the city, covering Highland, Lowland, Speyside and island bottles, alongside a cocktail list and a beer pour that gets real attention too. It's walk-in only, seven days, with staff who know the bottles well enough to talk you through them. Free pretzels at the bar have become something of a signature.
What people praise
- Staff know the whisky list inside out and will talk you through picks
- Atmosphere described as a genuinely unique, almost cinematic space
- Free pretzels at the bar
- Cocktails praised as well made, if pricier than a standard pub
Worth knowing
- No bookings, so it can be a wait to get a booth on busy nights
- Only a handful of booths, and it gets loud and crowded
Our take: The top spot on rating and volume both, and it holds that lead with 3,970 reviews behind it. Go for the whisky and the room itself, not a quiet catch-up.



