5 Best Real Estate Agents in Puyallup (2026)

Ranked by real Google ratings and review volume · How we chose

By Lorian Hartfield, Real Estate and Financial Expert · ✓ Updated October 2026 · 7 min read

We compared 19 real estate agents in Puyallup on Google Maps · 5 listed · How we rank

A perfect rating tells you very little when every name holds one, and that is the situation with real estate agents in Puyallup on this page: each carries a 5.0 on Google. What separates them is volume and whose story the reviews tell. Between them these agents have logged more than 800 reviews, from more than 100 for the smallest base to more than 250 for the largest, and the stories range from sellers to first-time buyers to clients moving in from other states.

Short answer: Kari Montgomery, REALTOR | Montgomery Home Team has the largest review base, with a 5.0 rating across more than 250 Google reviews, and Cascadia Home Team follows with more than 170 reviews at the same rating. Reviews skew toward sellers at Mike Mansour, and toward buyers at Cascadia and Robertson & Co.

Jump to a business

1. Kari Montgomery, REALT…
2. Cascadia Home Team
3. Kayla LaRance | Terraf…
4. Mike Mansour
5. Robertson & Co. powere…
Get listed

Puyallup Agents Compared by Who They Serve

#	Business	Rating	Reviews	Best for
1	Kari Montgomery, REALTOR \| Montgomery Home Team	5.0 ★	257	Home sellers, team support	View ›
2	Cascadia Home Team	5.0 ★	171	First-time and 55+ buyers	View ›
3	Kayla LaRance \| Terrafin Real Estate	5.0 ★	157	Out-of-state sellers and VA buyers	View ›
4	Mike Mansour - John L. Scott Real Estate	5.0 ★	111	Marketing and tough closings	View ›
5	Robertson & Co. powered by Terry Wise & Associates	5.0 ★	107	Relocating buyers, rental investors	View ›

5 Best Real Estate Agents in Puyallup (2026)

Meet the agents and teams

#1 Overall🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Kari Montgomery, REALTOR | Montgomery Home Team

5.0257 Google reviews

Kari Montgomery, REALTOR | Montgomery Home Team is a Keller Williams team at 1029 E Main Ave, Suite 201 in Puyallup. Its website covers buying, selling, home values and financing, with area search pages for Pierce, Thurston and King Counties. Reviews name several agents on the team, including Kayla Richardson and Kim Pettie, which points to a team model rather than a single agent.

What people praise

Sellers describe a smooth, organized sale, including one who sold a home from out of state
Communication praised as quick and thorough, with answers to every question
Multiple team members named in reviews for professionalism
A colleague describes the team as consistent and involved in its community

Worth knowing

Works as a team, so ask which agent will handle your sale

Reputation scorecardrank in Puyallup

Rating5 / 5

Review volume257 · 97th

Confidencehigh

Recency4 months ago

Info completenesssite · phone · hours

Rating breakdown99% 5-star

✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It carries the biggest review base on this page at a 5.0, and reviewers describe selling a home, including from out of state. A sensible first call if you are listing a home and want a team behind you.

Website +1253-318-6146 Directions

1029 E Main Ave Suite, 201, Puyallup, WA 98372

#2🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Cascadia Home Team

5.0171 Google reviews

Cascadia Home Team is a Pierce County real estate team, also under the Keller Williams banner, at 1029 E Main Ave #201. Its site says it serves Puyallup, Tacoma, Gig Harbor, Lakewood and DuPont and is led by Nancy Lee. Pages on the site cover buyers 55 and over, moves to Joint Base Lewis-McChord, and neighborhood guides for Puyallup, Sumner and Bonney Lake.

What people praise

Buyers describe patient, unhurried showings, in one case over six months
First-time buyers say paperwork was explained clearly
Agents recommended inspectors and lenders to buyers who needed them
A fellow agent who referred clients says she was kept informed throughout

Reputation scorecardrank in Puyallup

Rating5 / 5

Review volume171 · 92nd

Confidencemoderate

Recency3 months ago

Info completenesssite · phone · hours

Rating breakdown100% 5-star

✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A strong fit for people buying their first home or shopping as a 55-plus buyer, judging by the reviews and the site's buyer guides. Freda Kohler and Nancy Lee are the agents reviewers mention most.

Website +1253-222-9978 Directions

1029 E Main Ave #201, Puyallup, WA 98372

#3🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Kayla LaRance | Terrafin Real Estate

5.0157 Google reviews

Kayla LaRance | Terrafin Real Estate is an agent profile on Terrafin Real Estate's site, listed at 719 E Main Ave in Puyallup. Her bio says she has worked in real estate for about a decade and partners with Heather Stokes, with a stated commitment to first-time home buyers and military clients. Reviews cover both sides of a sale and purchase, often for people who were not in town.

What people praise

Sellers handled a whole transaction remotely, including coordinating clean-out, cleaning and staging
A buyer couple who bought a home sight unseen felt informed on every property
A fellow agent praises her handling of a first-time VA loan purchase
Responsive and organized communication, per several reviewers

Reputation scorecardrank in Puyallup

Rating5 / 5

Review volume157 · 87th

Confidencemoderate

Recency5 months ago

Info completenesssite · phone · hours

Rating breakdown99% 5-star

✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A strong match if you are managing a sale or purchase from another state, since several reviews describe exactly that.

Website +1253-682-9936 Directions

719 E Main Ave, Puyallup, WA 98372

#4🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Mike Mansour - John L. Scott Real Estate

5.0111 Google reviews

Mike Mansour - John L. Scott Real Estate is a Puyallup agent affiliated with John L. Scott, working from 429 29th St NE, Suite A, with business partner Sierra named alongside him in reviews. Sellers dominate the reviews, covering a townhouse, a custom home in Edgewood and a house with a septic certificate problem.

What people praise

Sellers praise marketing, staging and photography
One couple reports a full-price offer from the first, unscheduled showing
Persistent when a closing stalled, including calls to the county and a septic inspector
Prompt texts, emails and calls for a client selling from out of state

Reputation scorecardrank in Puyallup

Rating5 / 5

Review volume111 · 82nd

Confidencemoderate

Recency2 months ago

Info completenesssite · phone · hours

Rating breakdown100% 5-star

✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Pick this team if your priority is how the home is presented and how hard your agent will push when a deal hits trouble. Every one of its Google reviews is five stars.

Website +1253-213-1674 Directions

429 29th St NE Ste a, Puyallup, WA 98372

#5🕑 Open 6 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

Robertson & Co. powered by Terry Wise & Associates

5.0107 Google reviews

Robertson & Co. powered by Terry Wise & Associates is a Puyallup real estate team led by Austin Robertson, with Chris Titus named in reviews, listed at 1029 E Main Ave Suite 201 in Puyallup. Reviews come mostly from buyers, including people relocating from California and elsewhere and one investor who also set up a rental. Clients mention finding Austin through his Facebook group and videos about the area.

What people praise

Out-of-state buyers say the team made decisions feel confident
A rental-property buyer got a full team of local contacts, not just a house
A listing agent on the other side of a deal called the negotiation collaborative
Clients mention a helpful list of local inspectors, brokers and handymen

Reputation scorecardrank in Puyallup

Rating5 / 5

Review volume107 · 76th

Confidencemoderate

Recency3 months ago

Info completenesssite · phone · hours

Rating breakdown99% 5-star

✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Look here if you are moving to the area or buying an investment property. Its review base is the smallest on this page, though still above 100.

Website +1253-225-2395 Directions

1029 E Main Ave Suite, 201, Puyallup, WA 98372

Your business here

Get listed on this page, in front of local customers already searching for you.

Claim this spot ›

Reading the scorecards

Each card is built from the business’s public Google profile on the date shown. Rating is the live average, and review volume shows how many people have rated each agent against the others. Because the ratings here are almost identical, confidence, which weighs rating by volume, does most of the work separating them.

What do agents in Puyallup charge?

Commission rates are negotiated rather than fixed, and none of these agents lists them, so no figures appear here. Costs to ask about include the listing commission, any buyer-side commission, and what the brokerage charges separately. Get the terms in writing from each agent before you sign a listing or buyer agreement.

Offices and service areas

Every agent here lists a Puyallup address, most of them on E Main Ave and one on 29th St NE. Cascadia Home Team’s site names Puyallup, Bonney Lake, Federal Way, Gig Harbor, Graham, Lake Tapps and Sumner as areas it covers, and Montgomery Home Team’s site names Pierce, Thurston and King Counties. Each listing shows a phone number so you can ask about your own neighborhood.

Property Management Companies in Puyallup

What to ask before you sign with an agent

Will I work with you directly or with a team member, and who answers my calls?
How do you market a home, and what is included in photography and staging?
How do you handle closings when an inspection, lender or county issue slows things down?
Can you manage a sale or purchase if I am out of state?
What are your commission terms, in writing, before I sign?

Frequently asked questions

Which agent here suits first-time or 55-plus buyers?

Cascadia Home Team’s site has pages for buyers 55 and over and for moves to Joint Base Lewis-McChord, and its reviewers include first-time buyers who say the paperwork was explained clearly. Kayla LaRance’s bio also states a commitment to first-time home buyers and military clients.

Which Puyallup agents have reviews about selling a home versus buying one?

Reviews for Mike Mansour mostly describe sellers, and Montgomery Home Team’s include sellers, including one selling from out of state. Cascadia Home Team and Robertson & Co. are described mainly by buyers, and Kayla LaRance’s reviews cover both a remote sale and a sight-unseen purchase.

Can these agents handle a move from out of state?

Reviewers describe it at several of them: a remote sale of an inherited house with Kayla LaRance, a seller out of state with Mike Mansour and with Montgomery Home Team, and relocating buyers with Robertson & Co. Ask how they handle showings and signing at a distance.

Choosing among them

With every agent at a 5.0, match the one to your move. Montgomery Home Team or Mike Mansour for selling, Cascadia Home Team for a first or 55-plus purchase, and Kayla LaRance or Robertson & Co. if you are coming from out of state.

Best Real Estate And Property Services in other cities

More categories in Puyallup

Own one of these businesses, or want to be here?

Claim your spot on this page: Basic listing $50 or Premium $100 for the top spot, held a full year. Both include a permanent link to your site.

Get listed See pricing